Charles Dickens' A Christmas Carol, directed by a horror filmmaker, and scored by the composer who has worked with him for more than a decade. Ti West's new film Ebenezer opened in U.S. theaters on November 13, and its score album was released digitally the same day by Milan Records. The music is by Tyler Bates, and the tracklist reported by Film Music Reporter runs 25 cues.
Johnny Depp stars as Ebenezer Scrooge, the wealthy, bitter miser who faces a supernatural intervention on Christmas Eve in Victorian London. The supporting cast includes Rupert Grint, Andrea Riseborough, Daisy Ridley, Sam Claflin and Ian McKellen, and Paramount Pictures is distributing. When the director of X and Pearl retells the most heartwarming story everyone knows as a Gothic fantasy, the obvious question is: who makes it sound that way?
Bates and West: Collaboration Number Five
Tyler Bates is the composer of Guardians of the Galaxy, Deadpool 2, John Wick, 300, Atomic Blonde, Watchmen and Dawn of the Dead, someone who has raised the body temperature of action and genre cinema with heavy beats and guitar textures.
He also has a long history with Ti West. According to Film Music Reporter, Bates previously scored The Sacrament, X (co-scored with Chelsea Wolfe), Pearl (with Timothy Williams) and MaXXXine. Ebenezer makes it five films together.
What is fascinating is how different each of those scores sounds. X used Chelsea Wolfe's voice to evoke 1970s Texas dread, Pearl deliberately leaned into the lush orchestra of an old Hollywood melodrama, and MaXXXine moved to '80s synths. Every time the director changes era and genre, Bates changes instruments with him. This time the destination is Victorian London, and the score was reportedly recorded at Abbey Road Studios.
The Tracklist Doubles as a Map of the Story
Adding up the listed durations, the 25 cues come to roughly 46 minutes. The average cue is under two minutes, and even the longest, "Awful Sounds," is just 2:49. That suggests a structure that cuts quickly from scene to scene rather than one built on long suites.
Read the titles in order and anyone who knows the book will smile.
- "Marley is Dead": the novel's famous opening line, used as track 2 to open the door to the story.
- "Haunted Door Knocker": the iconic moment when Marley's face appears on the knocker.
- "Ghost of Christmas Past," "Ghost of Christmas Present," "Ghost of Christmas Yet to Come": each of the three spirits gets a cue of its own (tracks 5, 11 and 15).
- "Young Ebenezer," "Belle," "Lock of Hair": the young Scrooge and his former fiancée Belle. The past chapter is told through character-named cues.
- "Your Nightmare Has Just Begun," "Nightmare of the Future," "Look Death in the Eyes": the horror-leaning face of the Ti West version.
- "Christmas Supper," "Finale": and finally, supper.
Giving each of the three ghosts its own cue makes for a clear listening guide. Are Past, Present and Yet to Come written as variations on shared material, or painted in entirely different colors? Simply comparing them side by side should reveal how Bates built this film.
How Does a Horror Composer Land a Redemption Story?
A Christmas Carol is a story of transformation before it is a scary story. The back half of the tracklist includes "Good and Honest Man," "There's Still Some Time," "An Hour Once Ours" and "You Remind Me of Her," titles that suggest regret and redemption. How the score travels from a string of nightmares to the warmth of "Christmas Supper," and how a composer known for heavy beats handles that landing, may be the album's biggest point of interest.
The man who gave us classical orchestra in Pearl and synths in MaXXXine has now recorded a Gothic Christmas Carol at Abbey Road. With December around the corner, how about a score that is a little frightening and, at the end, a little warm? Start with track 2, "Marley is Dead," and open the door.